|Is there a genetic basis to psychological types?
There is a lot of modern evidence that psychological types have a biological basis, and
that introversion and extraversion are at least, in part, inherited. But specifics are
lacking. What we would like to do is go out on a limb and describe an insight that was
born out of many years of working with psychological types that we feel warrants further
exploration and discussion. The insight in a nutshell is that the children appear to have
the psychological attitude, that is, the introversion or extraversion, of the parent of
the opposite sex.
If both parents are extraverted, the children appear extraverted, and if both parents are introverted, they appear introverted. But when the parents have different psychological attitudes, that is, one is introverted and the other is extraverted, the children appear to follow the attitude of the parent of the opposite sex, so if the mother is introverted, the boys will be introverted, and if the father is extraverted, the girls will be extraverted. It is like the old saying, like fathers like daughters, like mothers like sons. (Although we have heard that saying turned around.)
Now anyone who has spent any amount of time trying to determine people's psychological types will realize how fraught with difficulties this process is. But let's suppose for a moment that there is a grain of truth to our observation. That would imply that one of the genes for introversion and extraversion is on the X-chromosome. In the associated reading we go much further out on a limb and pursue some of the evidence and implications for this theory of the genetic basis of introversion and extraversion.
Now it is your turn to contribute to this discussion. Send us your questions and comments: email@example.com
Curious about type and genetic introversion/extroversion. How would it be explained in
a family with four children, only one is introverted? The parents both seem extroverted,
but I can't tell for sure. They are always giving parties and the wife can't stand to be
alone for a minute. Three kids are extroverted and one is INTJ or ISTJ, the girl, second
in birth order. The oldest boy is extroverted as is the youngest girl. They just had a
fourth child a few months ago, a boy. Both parents appear to be ESTJ.
I've always thought that type was passed down kind of like blood type or eye color. That you will probably end up some combination of your parents and that there may be dominant and recessive tendencies. I knew one family where all four members (parents and children) were ISTP's. My dad is an ENTP and my mom an ISFJ. They have three daughters - an INFJ (myself), an ENFP, and an ISTJ. So I don't particularly think the idea that you have the same introversion/extroversion as your opposite sex parent holds water. Jan
You may be right. There is something going on in the genetics of psychological types, but it is hard to get at. I think it has something to do with the X-chromosome, and it might appear stronger in the connection between the mother's type and the son's type rather than between fathers and daughters, but all this is pretty much unexplored territory.
I think you may have something with the mother-son connection
being stronger since the X-chromosome is matched with the smaller Y chromosome as opposed
to the two equal X's found in daughters.
How to contribute to this discussion
Reading: Type and